Keep It or Sell It? What to Do With Your Seattle-Area Home When You Get PCS Orders
Quick Answer
Should you keep or sell your Seattle-area home when you get new PCS orders? Keep it if the rent covers the full monthly cost, you can manage it from afar and you’d own it anyway. Sell if the numbers run negative or you need the cash and entitlement.
New orders land, and suddenly a house you bought to live in becomes a business decision. Do you hand the keys to a tenant and keep building equity from three time zones away? Or do you sell, take the cash and start fresh at the next duty station?
There’s no single right answer. I’ve owned and managed rental property for over 20 years, including small multifamily, and I’ve watched both choices work out well and both go sideways. What separates them is usually the math and the logistics, not luck.
This guide walks through the questions to ask first, a side-by-side decision table, a sample rent-versus-cost calculation, what happens to your VA entitlement and your taxes, Washington’s landlord rules, and how to sell from out of state if that’s the call. If you’re earlier in the process, start with my guide to buying a home in the Seattle area with PCS orders.
Two Lenses: Your Home or Your Rental
A home that’s perfect to live in isn’t always a good rental. And the reverse is true too.
When you bought, you probably cared about the layout, the yard, the commute and how the neighborhood felt on a Saturday morning. A renter cares about some of that. But a rental lives or dies on different things: what it rents for compared to what it costs you each month, how close it is to the base or to job centers, how much maintenance it throws at you, and whether an HOA limits rentals.
So the first step is to look at your house with fresh eyes. Stop asking “do we love it?” and start asking “would I buy this today as an investment?” If the answer is no, that tells you a lot.

Four Questions to Answer First
Before we ever talk numbers, I ask families these four things. The answers often make the decision for you.
How Long Will You Be Gone, and Will You Come Back?
If there’s a real chance you’ll return to Naval Station Everett, JBLM or another Puget Sound assignment, or retire here, keeping the house can make a lot of sense. You hold your place in a market that’s hard to buy back into. If you’re leaving for good and have no ties here, the case for keeping gets weaker.
Can You Manage It From Afar, or Will You Hire a Property Manager?
Self-managing from another state, or another country, is possible. People do it with a good handyman, online rent collection and a lot of phone calls at odd hours. But a deployment, a new baby or a hard tour can make that impossible. Budget for a property manager even if you plan to do it yourself. If the numbers only work without one, they don’t really work.
Is This a Place to Live, an Investment, or Both?
Some families want a long-term rental portfolio built one duty station at a time. Others just want to avoid selling in a hurry. Both are fine goals. They lead to different answers, so be clear with yourself (and your spouse) about which one you’re chasing.
Do You Need the Cash or the Entitlement for Your Next Home?
If you plan to buy at the next station, your equity and your VA entitlement both matter. Keeping this house may mean a down payment on the next one, or a smaller loan amount with no money down. I’ll cover the entitlement rules in a minute, because they trip up a lot of people.
Keep or Sell: The Decision Table
Here’s how the common factors tend to lean. You won’t land on one side for every row. Look for where most of yours fall.
| Factor | Leans Keep | Leans Sell |
|---|---|---|
| Rent vs. full monthly cost | Rent covers everything, including management and repairs | You’d be feeding it hundreds a month with no end in sight |
| Your interest rate | A low locked-in rate you can’t get again | A higher rate with little equity built |
| Plans to return | Likely to come back or retire in Puget Sound | Leaving for good |
| Management | Reliable property manager or local help | No backup plan if you can’t answer the phone |
| Condition | Newer systems, low maintenance | Old roof, aging furnace, deferred projects |
| HOA rules | Rentals allowed with few limits | Rental caps or long waiting lists |
| Next purchase | Enough entitlement and savings to buy again | You need the equity or full entitlement |
| Taxes | You understand depreciation and plan for it | You’d lose the home sale tax exclusion by waiting too long |
| Your stress level | You want to be a landlord | You’d lie awake over a leaky water heater |
That last row matters more than people admit. Being a landlord is a job. Some people enjoy it. Some people hate every minute.
Run the Math: Rent vs. the Full Monthly Cost
Most families compare the rent to their mortgage payment and stop there. That’s where the trouble starts. A rental’s real monthly cost includes things you never think about while you live in a house.
- Principal, interest, taxes and insurance (PITI). Your full mortgage payment, including the escrow for property taxes.
- A landlord insurance policy. Your homeowner’s policy usually won’t cover a rental. A landlord (dwelling fire) policy often costs a bit more.
- HOA dues, if you have them.
- Property management. Usually a percentage of the monthly rent plus a leasing fee when a new tenant moves in. Get real quotes.
- Maintenance and big repairs. Roofs, water heaters and furnaces wear out on their own schedule, not yours.
- Vacancy. Even a great rental sits empty between tenants, and military tenants can leave early with orders (more on that below).
An Example With Round Numbers
To be clear, this is a made-up example to show the method, not a quote for your home. Picture a Snohomish County house bought with a VA loan a few years ago: a $600,000 loan at 3% for 30 years, renting for $3,600 a month. Your rent, taxes and insurance will be different, so plug in your own.
| Monthly Line Item (Example Only) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Rent collected | $3,600 |
| Principal and interest ($600,000 at 3%, 30 years) | -$2,530 |
| Property taxes | -$550 |
| Landlord insurance | -$150 |
| Property management (about 9% of rent) | -$324 |
| Maintenance and repairs reserve (about 8% of rent) | -$288 |
| Vacancy reserve (about 5% of rent) | -$180 |
| Monthly cash flow | -$422 |
| Principal paid down each month (early in the loan) | about +$1,030 |
See what happened? Even with a 3% rate, the house loses a little cash each month once you count everything. But the tenant is paying down about $1,000 a month of your loan, and you still own the appreciation. Self-manage and the gap nearly closes.
That’s the real question. Can you afford to cover a few hundred dollars a month, plus the occasional $8,000 roof surprise, in exchange for building equity? Some families can. Some can’t, especially right after a move, when everything costs more than planned.
If your loan has a higher rate or a newer, higher balance, the math usually gets worse fast. In the higher-cost parts of the Seattle area, rents often don’t keep up with recent purchase prices. I go deeper on that in my post on what landlords should know before buying a rental in Kenmore, and the same logic applies here.
Don’t Forget Your Locked-In Rate
A low rate is an asset you can’t buy back. If you sell a home with a 3% loan, the next loan will almost certainly cost more. That’s a strong reason to keep, as long as the rest of the numbers hold up. I wrote a whole post on this: Locked Into a Low Mortgage Rate? When Selling Anyway Makes Sense in Seattle.
What Selling Really Costs
Selling isn’t free either. When you compare the two paths, subtract the cost of selling from your equity to see what you’d actually walk away with.
In Washington, sellers usually pay real estate commissions (which are negotiable), the state real estate excise tax, title insurance for the buyer, escrow fees, and any prep or repairs. If you’re moving out before you sell, add utilities and insurance on a vacant house. For a full line-by-line breakdown, see What Does It Really Cost to Sell a House in Seattle?
The upside of selling is simple: you get cash, you’re done with the house, and you may get your full VA entitlement back for the next purchase.
What Happens to Your VA Entitlement
This is where a lot of military families get surprised. Your VA loan benefit isn’t used up forever, but it isn’t free to reuse either.
If you keep the house and the VA loan stays in place, the entitlement attached to that loan stays tied up. You may still have remaining entitlement to buy at your next station, but depending on the price and county loan limits, you might need a down payment. Your lender can run the exact numbers from your Certificate of Eligibility.
If you sell and pay off the VA loan, the VA says you can have your used entitlement restored for future use. And there’s a one-time option: if you pay off the loan in full but keep the property (say, by refinancing into a conventional loan), you can have your entitlement restored once.
| What You Do | What Happens to Your Entitlement |
|---|---|
| Keep the house, keep the VA loan | That entitlement stays tied up; you may use any remaining entitlement |
| Sell and pay off the VA loan | You can request restoration of your used entitlement |
| Keep the house but pay off the VA loan (refinance or pay cash) | One-time restoration is available |
| Sell to a buyer who assumes your VA loan | Restored only if the buyer is an eligible veteran who substitutes their own entitlement |
Talk to a VA-savvy lender before you decide. If you need one, here’s my list of recommended lenders. You can also grab my free guide, Using Your VA Entitlement, which covers the basics in a few pages.
Taxes: The Military Break Most People Miss
I’m not a CPA, and you should talk to one before you decide. But here’s the part that changes the decision for many military homeowners.
The Home Sale Exclusion
When you sell a home you’ve owned and lived in for at least two of the last five years, you can usually exclude up to $250,000 of gain from income, or $500,000 if you’re married filing jointly. That’s from IRS Publication 523.
Rent the house out for too long, and you can fail that two-out-of-five test. That’s the trap.
The Military Suspension
Members of the uniformed services can elect to suspend the five-year test period while on qualified official extended duty, for up to 10 years. In plain English, your time away on orders may not count against you. That can let you rent the house for years and still sell with the exclusion. Check the details in Publication 523 with your tax preparer, because the rules on what counts as qualified duty are specific.
Depreciation Comes Back Later
Once it’s a rental, you depreciate the building over 27.5 years, which lowers your taxable rental income. But IRS Publication 527 notes that depreciation, even the amount you could have taken and didn’t, reduces your basis when you sell. That depreciation is generally taxed when you sell, even if the rest of the gain is excluded. Plan for it.

Being a Washington Landlord From Out of State
Washington is not a casual place to be a landlord. The rules protect tenants, and they apply whether you live down the street or in Japan.
The Residential Landlord-Tenant Act
Washington’s Residential Landlord-Tenant Act, RCW 59.18, sets the rules for deposits, repairs, entry, notices and evictions. Since 2021, landlords generally need a specific legal cause to evict or to end most tenancies, under RCW 59.18.650. That includes some causes owners care about, like moving back in or selling, but each one has its own notice period and paperwork.
Washington also passed a statewide cap on annual rent increases, with advance notice rules (House Bill 1217). The details and exemptions matter, so have your property manager or an attorney walk you through how they apply to your home.
Seattle Adds Another Layer
If your home is inside Seattle city limits, you’ll deal with extra city rules. Most Seattle rentals must register with the Rental Registration and Inspection Ordinance (RRIO) and pass an inspection at least once every five to 10 years if selected. Seattle has its own tenant protections on top of the state’s.
That’s one reason a house in Everett, Mill Creek or Marysville can be simpler to own from a distance than one in Seattle. It’s not that suburban landlords skip the rules. There are just fewer layers.
Renting to Military Families? Plan for Early Moves
Military tenants are often great tenants. But under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, a service member who gets PCS orders, deployment orders for 90 days or more, or separation or retirement orders can end a lease early without penalty, according to the Department of Justice’s SCRA guide. You’ve been on the other side of that, so you know it happens. Build a bigger vacancy reserve if your house is likely to rent to military families.
Insurance, HOA and Your Lender
- Switch to a landlord policy before the tenant moves in. A homeowner’s policy on a rented house can leave you uncovered.
- Read your HOA’s rental rules. Some limit how many units can be rented or require a minimum lease length.
- VA loans require you to intend to live in the home when you buy. Renting it after you’ve lived there and then received orders is a normal part of military life, but tell your lender and servicer where to reach you.
If You Sell: Timing and Selling Remotely
If the numbers say sell, the next question is when. You have three main options.
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| List before you leave | You can handle repairs and showings in person | Showings while you’re packing and living there |
| List after you leave, house vacant | Clean, staged, easy to show; often photographs best | You carry the mortgage, utilities and insurance on an empty house |
| Sell with a tenant in place | Rent covers costs while you sell; can appeal to investors | Harder showings, tenant notice rules, fewer owner-occupant buyers |
Selling from another state works fine with the right local help. I handle showings, contractors, inspections and offer reviews, and we sign documents electronically. Many closings can use a mobile notary or a remote option where you are. The key is a tight plan, so a sale doesn’t wobble when you can’t be there. I explain what usually derails a sale in How to Keep Your Seattle Home Sale From Falling Through.
If you’re buying at your next station at the same time, timing gets tricky. A sale that drags can stress the people on the other end. I saw that with a recently retired Army recruiter I helped buy in Sequim. His loan took about three extra weeks to close, and the seller was anxious because he was buying his next home in Tacoma at the same time. Everyone got there, but it’s a good reminder to build in a cushion.
How I Help You Decide
I’ll run both scenarios for your actual house: what it would likely rent for, what it would likely sell for, and what each path puts in your pocket. Because I’ve been a landlord since 2002, I can tell you what a property manager will really charge and what tends to break. And if selling is the better call, I’ll tell you that too.
If you’re also thinking about your next purchase in the Puget Sound area, my military relocation guide for the Seattle area covers where families live, how VA loans work here and how to buy before you arrive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I rent out my VA loan home when I PCS?
Yes. VA loans require you to intend to live in the home when you buy, but renting it out after you’ve lived there and then received orders is common. Your entitlement stays tied to that loan while you keep it.
Will I owe capital gains tax if I rent my house before selling?
Possibly. You usually need to have lived in the home two of the last five years to use the $250,000 or $500,000 exclusion, but service members on qualified official extended duty can suspend the five-year period for up to 10 years. Depreciation taken while it was a rental is generally still taxable, so check with a CPA.
Can I get my VA entitlement back if I keep my house?
Only once, and only if the VA loan is paid in full, for example by refinancing into another loan type. Otherwise, the entitlement stays tied up, but you may still have remaining entitlement for your next purchase.
Is it hard to be a landlord in Washington from out of state?
It takes planning. Washington’s landlord-tenant law requires specific causes and notices to end most tenancies, and Seattle adds rental registration and inspections. Most out-of-state owners hire a local property manager.
Can a military tenant break my lease?
Yes. Under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, a tenant who receives PCS orders, deployment orders of 90 days or more, or separation orders can end a lease early without penalty. Budget extra for vacancy if you rent to military families.
Let’s Run Your Numbers
Got orders and a house to figure out? I’ll put together a rent estimate and a sale estimate for your home so you can compare them side by side, with no pressure either way.
- Call or text: 206-245-8813
- Book a free call: pick a time that works for you
- Free guide: Using Your VA Entitlement
- More about me: HomeProAssociates.com
Emily Cressey, Military Relocation Agent and Broker, HomePro Associates at Keller Williams Greater Seattle, serving King and Snohomish Counties.
A shout-out to PCS Masters: I’m proud to be a partner agent with PCS Masters, a network that coaches military families through the whole move, from money and planning to finding a trusted agent at each new duty station. Here’s how PCS Masters and I work together.

About the Author: Emily Cressey
Emily Cressey is a REALTOR® with HomePro Associates at Keller Williams Greater Seattle and a PCS Masters partner agent. She loves working with military families, veterans, and service members, and it shows in how she works: she knows how to make a VA offer compete, how to line up a purchase with your report date, and how to tell whether a duplex or fourplex really pencils out. She has helped a retired Navy officer buy his first home in Lynnwood and an Army recruiter retire to Sequim. With over 20 years of industry experience (she became an investor in 2002), she also helps you think past move-in day to whether the house will still work for you as a rental when your next orders come.
PCSing to JBLM or Naval Station Everett, or using your VA loan here? Call or text Emily at 206-245-8813, or book a free call. We make real estate EASY for you.
WA Real Estate License #20109399 · Verify at WA DOL


